Posts Tagged ‘scotus’

A Very Lame Argument

March 4, 2013


The case against same-sex marriage is being heard before the Supreme Court and the opponents of the right that is legal in nine states is using an unusual argument: unwanted pregnancy.

This stems from the single opposing view of the Massachusetts Supreme Court when the law was passed.

Massachusetts Justice Robert Cordy explained in his dissent that the government does have a stake in defining marriage as only between men and women because unwanted pregnancies result in the couples marrying and creating a “stable family” which then becomes the bulwark of society. It was the government’s responsibility then to ensure the male of the couple is sent the strong message to wed and help in rearing the children.

What the heck was this guy smoking?!

The statistics on couples that got married “because they had to” are not good, usually ending in divorce, battered wives, and a number of other problems not conducive to Justice Cordy’s (or anyone else’s) idea of a stable society.

And since WHEN do people get married for the good of the society?

Last time I checked, people got married because they wanted to share a life together, not for any statistical chart over at Health and Human Services.

And his idea of “sending a strong message” to young men not ready or willing to become supportive partners and parents is not anywhere near working.

Again, I can only ask what the heck was this guy smoking?!

But, as completely stupid as this reasoning sound, his argument has been cited in practically every suit opposing gay marriage since 2003!!

Maybe these guys are smoking the same thing.

First off, we really need less government involvement in our daily lives and we sure as hell(!) need less church in our government.

Separation of church and state was mandated for a reason and this religious pressure was exactly that reason.

Enforce your religious views on yourselves and not on everyone else.

(says so in both the Holy Bible and the Constitution)